Comerford, Domb push for ‘accountability’ on the green and healthy schools

The debate highlights a growing ideological divide between conservatives, who have advocated for expanding nontraditional educational approaches demonstrated by charter and private schools, and progressives, who have argued the state should devote more resources to supporting existing learning in public schools.

The debate highlights a growing ideological divide between conservatives, who have advocated for expanding nontraditional educational approaches demonstrated by charter and private schools, and progressives, who have argued the state should devote more resources to supporting existing learning in public schools. Photo by Dave Cummings

By EDEN MOR

For the Gazette

Published: 10-23-2023 10:06 AM

Two Pioneer Valley lawmakers are seeking a more concrete plan — including the creation of a “watchdog group” — to improve the health of public school buildings and reduce their environmental impact throughout the commonwealth.

Sen. Jo Comerford, D-Northampton, and Rep. Mindy Domb, D-Amherst, were able to incorporate several pieces of their proposal for healthy and green public schools as part of a major bill focused on clean energy and offshore wind. That bill passed last year as part of the Legislature’s 2021-2022 session.

Their goal was to collect data on the health of school buildings, including their energy and resource efficiency, in order to limit exposure to toxic chemicals and create an environment that is “conducive to learning,” according to the original bill.

“It was really an exciting and pretty sweeping bill,” Comerford said of the measure, which “urged the collection of real data” on the conditions of school buildings and their infrastructure.

As a follow-up, the lawmakers this legislative session are proposing the creation of a working group and implementation plan to create a “watchdog group” to monitor progress on reaching the goals established by the previous bill.

Comerford said she began to pursue the original piece of legislation in reaction to several issues brought to her attention during the COVID-19 pandemic. At a time when ventilation was important to the safety of students and faculty, Comerford found that old school buildings were unable to open their windows, creating severe health hazards.

Where some communities with newer buildings could afford new HVAC systems, others fell behind.

“To see the older buildings in largely the poor communities really disproportionately struggle from a public health sense was wrenching,” Comerford said.

Article continues after...

Yesterday's Most Read Articles

Nicotine pouch ban would hurt business, Athol convenience store owners say
Athol Chief Joseph Guarnera reflects on six years with Fire Department
With third location in Turners Falls, Community Health Center to serve another 4,000 patients
In address at UMass, U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib cheers on those who faced consequences for supporting Palestine at flagship last spring
Ed board chair: Lawsuit anticipated in wake of MCAS vote
Thanksgiving football: Hot start more than enough to propel Athol past rival Mahar, 26-0 (PHOTOS)

Though the data being collected on the health of school buildings is still in process and not yet available to the public, Comerford expects it to be “pretty revolutionary.”

The collection requires collaboration among the Department of Elementary and Secondary Education, the Massachusetts School Building Authority, the Department of Public Health and the Department of Environmental Protection, Comerford said.

Domb and Comerford are still looking for that final push to make their plan “actionable,” Domb said during her testimony before a September hearing before the Legislature’s Education Committee.

“[We need to] make sure that those plans are not only effective, and doable, but get implemented,” she said.

The green and healthy schools bill is part of a larger effort by state government to achieve net-zero carbon emissions by 2050. Comerford said this goal is specifically applicable to western Massachusetts, which reduces and sequesters carbon emissions through its open working lands.

The bill allows Massachusetts to tackle emissions from the “built environment,” an opportunity that rarely presents itself despite the fact that “between 30 and 40% of all global warming carbon emissions come from the built environment,” Comerford said.

The lawmakers hope that they can build on last session’s momentum.

“Right now what we have is we have an administration and a Legislature that is dedicating money and we have a federal government dedicating money to schools to school buildings,” Comerford said. “But we don’t have a roadmap.”

Eden Mor writes for the Gazette as part of the Boston University Statehouse Program.