Laura Briggs: We can't securitize our way out of school shootings

Two students view a memorial Thursday as flags fly half-staff after a shooting Wednesday at Apalachee High School in Winder, Ga.

Two students view a memorial Thursday as flags fly half-staff after a shooting Wednesday at Apalachee High School in Winder, Ga. AP PHOTO/MIKE STEWART

Published: 09-11-2024 11:39 AM

The other night, my kid had a nightmare about guns. I bet he wasn’t the only one, in the wake of all the publicity about the Apalachee High School shooting.

The New York Times reported afterward that the Georgia school contracted with a private security firm to respond to just such an event, and a week earlier school personnel had received personal “panic buttons” to contact the police. But I have to ask, would four people be alive now if the school had spent money on counselors and mental health instead?

We learned from Colt Gray’s aunt that the 14-year old had been “begging” for mental health treatment. The FBI questioned him when he was 13. School shootings do not come as a surprise. One kid who shot up a school had carried the nickname “school shooter” for years. At Parkland High School in Florida, part of the shock of the 2018 shooting there was that kids had said for years that they were mortally afraid of Nikolas Cruz.

This is the great fallacy of “active shooter drills” — school shooters come from the community. These drills just tell potential shooters what the response would be, while terrorizing the rest of the kids. At the same time, school shootings remain extraordinarily rare; the chance of being killed in one is about one in 614 million, according to a Washington Post report.

What if, instead of giving kids nightmares about an event that is less likely than getting killed by lightning or a shark attack, we supported counseling and treatment for kids who are struggling? Instead of locking school doors, maybe we need to care for those inside.

Laura Briggs

Northampton

Article continues after...

Yesterday's Most Read Articles

Nicotine pouch ban would hurt business, Athol convenience store owners say
Athol Chief Joseph Guarnera reflects on six years with Fire Department
With third location in Turners Falls, Community Health Center to serve another 4,000 patients
In address at UMass, U.S. Rep. Rashida Tlaib cheers on those who faced consequences for supporting Palestine at flagship last spring
Ed board chair: Lawsuit anticipated in wake of MCAS vote
Thanksgiving football: Hot start more than enough to propel Athol past rival Mahar, 26-0 (PHOTOS)